Anthony Robinson, Logging and Sawmilling Publisher and CEO, recently sat down to talk with Peter Lister, Executive Director of the Truck Loggers Association (TLA), about the B.C. forest industry being at a breaking point, and the mill closures, dire fibre supply situation and B.C. being among the highest—if not the highest—cost regions in the forest industry in North America.
Note: This is an edited transcript—for the full interview, please go to the Forestnet Media podcast on LSJ’s website: https://rss.com/podcasts/forestnet-media-podcast/2459952/
Anthony Robinson/Logging and Sawmilling Journal:
Peter, welcome to the Forestnet Media podcast. Thank you for joining us here in North Vancouver. Peter’s been an industry leader for 25 years, leading groups at FPInnovations, at Seaspan and has had a long career in leadership journeys—and has recently joined the Truck Loggers Association, which is a group that has a long history in British Columbia, representing logging contractors, and forestry communities.
Peter, we’d like to learn more about your career, your involvement in the forest industry and your leadership journey, and how the Truck Loggers Association is advocating for the forest industry in a time of much change and controversy. As you’ve mentioned before, there’s certainly a lot of challenges in the forest sector right now.
Peter Lister: The B.C. Interior used to be the lowest cost lumber producing region in North America. Today, we’re actually, if not the highest, we’re among the highest. Those high operating costs mean that we’re the first to shut down. And we’re seeing that right across the province.
I’ve been involved in the forest sector for over 35 years, and I’ve never seen it as tough as it is right now. With the recent closure of Domtar’s Crofton pulp mill on Vancouver Island, there’ll be something like 700 to 1,000 workers and families impacted, if you take the indirect jobs into consideration. And we’re seeing Canadian investment move across the border into the U.S. and into the U.S. South which has now become the cheapest producer in North America.
If there’s not markets for pulp logs in B.C., if there’s not markets for the chips that come from the sawmills, those sawmills will have to shut down as well. So, this could have a cascading effect. We’ve been talking to the government about this for months and months and months.
LSJ: Let’s talk about the role of the Truck Loggers Association. The TLA has been advocating for the industry in British Columbia for 80 years. How has that role evolved over the years and related to today’s forestry climate?
Lister: As I mentioned, I’ve never seen it as tough as it is right now. And I think that view is probably echoed by a lot of the people that you’re talking to and certainly that’s what I’m hearing from TLA members—we’re going through a period of a perfect storm of challenges.
We’ve got the whole situation with the U.S., with current duty and tariff levels around 45 per cent for most of the lumber producers. That has an enormous impact on the entire forest sector. Whether you’re a harvesting contractor, a TLA member, a pulp mill, a pellet mill, or value-added mill, that has a really big impact.
But those types of things are cyclical. You know, that’ll turn around in time.
We’re also going through what I would say are generational changes. And so B.C.’s adoption of UNDRIP (United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples) and DRIPA (Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act) is one of those generational changes. And because of the impacts of that legislation on the land base, which of course forestry operates on, it’s having an enormous impact on the forest sector in general and on TLA members.
The Truck Loggers has had to adjust just like the whole industry has had to adjust. A lot of those changes in the long term will be very positive. We’ll see more involvement with First Nations in the resource sector. I view that as a very positive thing. They’ve been excluded from the economic benefits of the resource activities that happen on their land base for far too long. So, those changes, I think, are really good. At the TLA, we’ve kind of pivoted to this new reality.
We will continue to be a strong advocate for our members, for the loggers, the suppliers, the communities that are TLA members and are dependent on the forest sector.
LSJ: How does that impact on the industry affect Truck Logger members?
Lister: Our members are at the front end of the supply chain and so they’re the people and the organizations that are going out there and harvesting the timber and transporting them to the mills. So, there’s a huge impact.
It’ll affect logging volumes. There will be less demand for pulp fiber. That creates issues in the forest sector in general because when we log, we get a mix of sawlogs and pulp logs. And so, then the question is, well, what happens to those pulp logs? What do we do with those? There’s not enough demand for those domestically.
We have to find other uses for those logs if we want to keep the sawmills operating. We’re really concerned about it.
We’ve been talking to the government about this for months and months and months, and you know, unfortunately, here we are. It’s largely driven by the lack of fiber availability in the case of Crofton, which is a tragedy because it is something that’s in our control in B.C.
LSJ: And when you talk about lack of fiber availability, let’s break that down a little bit. Fibre supply has been an issue that has affected the industry a lot in the last few years. We’re hearing reports that say the annual allowable cut has been overestimated and that fiber supply is actually way less than what British Columbia has been allowing every year.
Lister: Forestry is a complex industry and it’s very integrated and it’s really widely misunderstood.
There are so many misconceptions that are out there about forestry. I mean, you mentioned the controversy about the calculation for the annual allowable cut. It’s a great example of that misinformation or maybe people just not understanding how that is set. So, in British Columbia, we have a chief forester’s office. It’s an independent office.
They have a process that they go through to look at what sustainable fibre yields are in in the different forest management areas across species. It’s a very rigorous process, where they look at species growth rates in different parts of the affected area that they’re looking at.
They look at the probability of insect attack, fire, timber losses, all those types of things, and they’re tasked with determining what can be harvested each year on a sustainable basis. It’s very technical. The report that was quoted in the media recently I think was poking at some of the assumptions and saying, well, maybe those assumptions aren’t accurate and we should revisit those.
I think having that kind of dialogue around what are those assumptions and are they still valid today, well, that’s fair. But to suggest that there’s this sort of deliberate campaign or effort to mislead the public and skew the results of the AAC calculations and overestimate the amount of fiber that can be sustainably harvested, I think that’s just a gross mischaracterization.
You know, these are professional people, professional foresters. They have ethical standards that they have to follow. It’s misleading—what is being alleged is just not happening.
The thought that we’re going out there and harvesting trees at an unsustainable level, it’s almost a blow to the professionals that do that on a on a yearly basis. It’s kind of offensive, actually.
Some of it I think is just people not understanding what the process is because it is very technical. The industry itself, and I would include the Ministry of Forests in that basket, we’ve really done a poor job of talking to the public and explaining to them how these things work.
You know, the annual allowable cut is just the maximum sustainable yield that could be harvested. We’re harvesting at levels that are way below that. And the reasons for that are not because we can’t harvest more. There’s a whole complex range of issues of why we’re not harvesting more than we are. But the narrative is that, oh my god, we’re running out of trees—we’re way over-harvesting. And that’s really not the case.
LSJ: What’s holding that process up and why is there such a fibre supply issue?
Lister: Speaking generally about fibre supply in the province, I’d say that there’s really two major issues right now. One is the processes that industry has to go through to get a cutting permit. And the other is just the economics of it.
The processes have changed significantly over the years. Some of those changes are to promote better forest management. Some of them are in response to community concerns about things like viewscape.
People don’t like to see clearcuts in the hills above their communities. And so, foresters now have to take that those visual attributes into account when they’re doing their planning.
But there’s been layer upon layer of legislative changes that have been applied in B.C. that make the job of planning for a cutblock much more complex and adds a lot of cost to the process.
Just to give you an idea of the impacts on costs, I was talking to one of our members a few weeks ago. They were telling me that their average cost for planning and getting a cutting permit to the stage where it can be submitted has gone from $4 a cubic metre to $14 a cubic metre over about the last four years.
LSJ: That’s a huge increase!
Lister: Yes—if you think about it, we harvest about 30 million cubic metres right now in B.C., so, an extra $10 per cubic metre in planning costs, that’s $300 million more in costs to the industry. What business can sustain a more than three times increase in the cost of just getting to permits?
LSJ: To tell any business, oh, your cost has gone up by three times. It’s hard to believe, right?
Lister: Added to that, we have a requirement in B.C., which is a legislated requirement with DRIPA for free, prior, and informed consent. That requirement essentially means that you need to put real meaningful effort into reaching agreement with First Nations where you’re doing the forestry activities and reaching consensus on what you can do and what you can’t do.
I think in general that’s a good thing—these are their traditional territories. They should have a say in what happens there. But what’s happening right now is we’re in this kind of transition period, and a lot of the bands are completely overwhelmed by requests, not just to review and approve forestry permits, but it’s everything that’s happening on their land base.
The bands in rural areas are relatively small. They don’t have the resources to be able to respond to these requests easily or quickly.
The forest industry is finding that consultation process with nations is typically taking around 18 months right now. And 24 to 36 months is not uncommon. So, if you’ve gone through that planning process, you’re going into consultations which don’t just happen at the end of the planning process. They’re sort of continuing.
You know, in three years a lot can happen to the markets. And so that block that you’ve laid out that you thought you would be able to harvest might not be the fibre that you need any more because the markets have changed.
You’ll hear people say that, well, you know, there’s x million cubic metres under permit. How come we’re not harvesting that? Well, the reason is because in a lot of cases, and this brings me to the second point, because of the changes in the market, it’s either not the right fibre for the lumber products that we’re trying to produce or at the current lumber prices, we just can’t afford to log it. And so that second piece, that economic access to fibre, is really critical.
LSJ: You know the B.C. Interior used to be the lowest cost lumber producing region in North America. Right today we’re actually if not the highest, we’re among the highest.
Lister: When markets are hard, when lumber prices are low and we have these high U.S. duties and tariffs, essentially those high operating costs mean that we’re the first to shut down.
And we’re seeing that right across the province. And we’re seeing Canadian investment move across the border into the U.S. and into the U.S. South, which has now become the cheapest producer—because in North America, they can produce logs in Georgia and Texas in the U.S. South for far cheaper than they can in British Columbia.
People are very critical of the big forest companies for doing that. And I would say a couple of things. One, is that generally speaking, industry is pretty rational. They are companies that were built in B.C., companies like Canfor, West Fraser, Tolko, Western Forest Products—those are all B.C. companies, and most of them are publicly traded. They have shareholders that they’re accountable to. Those shareholders are in many cases the pension funds that are investing for my pension, your pension. And they have pressures on them to achieve certain returns for their stakeholders.
And so, there’s enormous pressure on forest product companies to find ways to return value to their shareholders. And it’s been a very lumpy ride. And today in British Columbia, the province is basically uninvestable for forestry. And so those capital dollars are going into other areas. They’re going into Alberta a lot, which has a much more competitive business environment. And then because of the U.S. tariffs, they are going more and more into the U.S. as well.
LSJ: There’s an understanding in B.C. that First Nations partnerships are a very meaningful and very important part of forestry today and in many other industries like you mentioned, mining and energy. The issue you mentioned before is timing, with getting permits. How do we balance meaningful reconciliation and meaningful involvement of First Nations groups with the need to produce timber, with the need to feed forest operations, in a reasonable amount of time. Like you said, 24 months is a tough time. How do we balance that? And how is the Truck Loggers helping regain balance in that process?
Lister: It’s a really great question and a question that doesn’t have easy answers. The provincial government is moving to a model of co-governance on the land base and there’s some really good reasons why they’re adopting that model rather than using the courts to settle land claims.
And I think the industry in general is very supportive of that approach. That transition though to a co-governance model requires First Nation governments to come together with our provincial government and negotiate what that looks like. So that takes time.
Another example is the forest land plans that are that are going on right now. So, we started with five pilots—we have about 15 of them right now in the province. I think one is kind of across the line and relatively complete. The objective of those is, I think, really good. The idea is to engage communities and stakeholders, including First Nations, in discussions about what happens to the land base around those communities.
The forest industry can’t just stop while we’re going through those processes, and so one of the challenges we have is what do we do in the transition? How do we keep fibre flowing? You know, how do we keep forestry workers like TLA members working, mill workers working, while we take the time to put together very thoughtful, detailed plans about how we want to manage our forests.
So, we’re having a lot of discussions with government about that. What we’re basically saying to them is that we think they need to take a triage approach where they need to work with First Nations right at the beginning of the process to quickly identify areas that are off limits to forestry, areas where there are no issues at all for forestry.
And then there’s going to be some areas in the middle where we’re not sure yet.
But let’s focus on those areas where we know that there’s no issues and let’s keep fibre moving from those areas while we go through the detailed planning process. That’s an approach that’s going to benefit everybody including First Nations.
LSJ: I sense a lot of optimism in your voice even during this time of crisis, Peter. What gives you that sense of optimism about the forestry sector? You’ve seen the ups and downs over your career. And I’ve seen maybe less ups, and more downs, in my career in British Columbia. A lot of downs in the last few years. What gives you that optimism, Peter?
Lister: Fundamentally, when you look at B.C. at a global level, our forests are the envy of the world. We have vast forests. We have very high-quality fibre. We can turn that fibre into wood products to build beautiful wood buildings, into other products that the world needs. Turning paper products increasingly into other types of materials. You know, the whole area around biomaterials and this idea of pulp mills evolving into these sorts of material refineries. Refineries may be not the right word, but we can extract all kinds of different materials out of wood products, to use for biofuels, to use for adhesives, bioplastics, all these different things.
And then the ability to do forestry in a sustainable way so that a thousand years from now we can still be doing this. We can still have healthy forests. That’s what gives me optimism. We need to do a better job of getting that story out, of continuing to improve the practices that we have, but we should be celebrating forestry.
We should be supporting it and the jobs that it provides, and the environmental benefits that come from it through building skyscrapers out of wood instead of concrete, for example.
I think we can get there. That’s what we’re working towards at TLA and advocating hard for—and that gives me hope.














0 Comments