Subscribe Archives Events ContactTimberWestMadison's Lumber DirectoryAdvertiseMedia Kit LSJ Home Forestnet

Untitled Document

Logging and Sawmilling Journal October/November 2011

March/April 2013

On the Cover:
With the re-opening of Canfor’s Radium, B.C. sawmill, and a resulting increase in work, M & H Logging recently purchased a new John Deere 2454D log loader. Read all about how M & H Logging handles harvesting wood on steep slopes in southeastern B.C. in this issue. (Photo by Tony Kryzanowski)

Lakeland Mills to be rebuilt
The Sinclar Group, owner of Lakeland Mills, has announced that they will rebuild their mill in Prince George, B.C. and have it operating in 2014; a fire and explosion destroyed the mill in 2012.

Multi-million dollar upgrade for EACOM Timber’s Nairn Centre mill
EACOM Timber is ramping up its operations in Ontario, starting with a major multi-million dollar investment in its Nairn Centre sawmill, near Sudbury.

Canada’s Top Lumber Producers —Who’s on top
Working with the International Wood Markets Group, Logging and Sawmilling’s annual listing of the Top Lumber Producers in Canada.

Steep slope logging
Veteran logger Clayton Mattson brings a wide variety of skills to his work harvesting wood on steep slopes in southeastern B.C. for Canfor’s newly-reopened Radium sawmill.

Sharpening sawfiling skills
An innovative Sawfiling Peer Group at Tolko Industries is helping to bridge the gap between sawfilers, mill management and company divisions.

Ledwidge Lumber weathers the storm
Nova Scotia’s Ledwidge Lumber has weathered elements of the Perfect Storm—including a hurricane and a blizzard—in years past. That’s behind them, though, and the long-established lumber producer is now well-prepared for the recovery, with a modern sawmill equipment set-up.

Industry rebound leads to ramping up on the Island
Harvesting activities are ramping up for Vancouver Island logger Matt Roberts—and as a result, he’s invested in some new Link-Belt iron to do log processing, log loading and roadbuilding on the rugged B.C. Coast.

Peak equipment performance
Tamarack Timber Services operates in the demanding oil patch salvage logging business in Alberta which—with drilling rigs costing out at $100,000 a day—requires logging equipment to perform within very defined production windows.

Custom Cutter
B.C.’s Dove Creek Timber has developed a solid market niche for its
custom and specialty lumber products, with the company making sales to customers from Nanaimo to New Zealand.

The Edge
Included in The Edge, Canada’s leading publication on research in the forest industry, are stories from the Canadian Wood Fibre Centre, Alberta Innovates

Tech Update — skidders


The Last Word


Bookmark and Share  Or CLICK to download a pdf of this article

The Last Word

The ethanol market is looking likea smart bet for the forest industry

By Tony Kryzanowski

Making ethanol from wood fibre is nothing new. But making enough ethanol to meet the world’s growing demand? Now, that’s a new chapter in this story that seems to be getting better and better every day for the Canadian forest industry. That’s especially so after the recent drought in the American Midwest corn belt and with new ethanol production technology using wood fibre as the main feedstock on the horizon.

But why should the forest industry care about this commodity?

One of the main reasons is that an upcoming change in the American renewable fuel standard will require the ethanol component in a gallon of gas be increased from 10 to 15 per cent. The current market for ethanol in the U.S. alone is worth a staggering $30 billion per year. That is expected to increase to $90 billion per year by 2022.

The knock on ethanol production from corn has long been the use of a potential food product to produce energy. Another complaint has been the amount of energy it takes to ferment one litre of ethanol from corn.

Many have argued that the American government’s support of ethanol production in the corn belt is uneconomical, and is nothing more than a subsidy to farmers to win votes.

However, ethanol production from wood fibre addresses both the food and energy argument. Many Canadian forestry operations have invested in bio-energy plants, using their own waste materials to generate power. By consuming their own bio-energy and using wood fibre—a non-food raw material—to produce ethanol, there is no doubt in my mind that forest companies should be global leaders in ethanol production.

A knock against cellulosic ethanol production has been the cost of production versus producing ethanol from corn. Well, an Ontario-based company, Woodland Biofuels, has an answer for that.

Woodland Biofuels has developed an ethanol production process—that avoids the expensive fermentation process—using all types of wood fibre as its main feedstock. The company’s chief executive officer recently told me that Woodland Biofuels expects its production cost to be lower than the cost of producing gasoline at today’s prices. They are putting the final touches on a $12 million demonstration plant in Sarnia, Ontario and are looking for forest industry partners to help commercialize their technology.

A growing market for ethanol and the arrival of new technology are both good arguments for more use of wood fibre in ethanol production, but there is also another, more fundamental reason why wood fibre should be the foundational raw material of this industry: it would be plain foolish to base the entire production of ethanol on corn. Why? The simple answer is weather. The drought in the American Midwest last year helps to prove my point.

Another good example of how dangerous it is to base a non-food industry on an agriculture feedstock is a straw fibre, panelboard plant built years ago in a place called Wanham near Grande Prairie, Alberta. The science was lined up so that it became technically and economically feasible to make a panelboard product by mixing resins with straw to compete with wood fibre-based panelboard like medium density fibreboard (MDF). It’s the material often found in cupboards and kitchen counter tops.

What happened? About six years of drought in the Peace River area resulted in very little local straw for the panelboard plant to use. It eventually did switch to wood fibre, but the transitional cost of investing in new equipment and trying to mesh the manufacturing equipment intended for agriculture fibre processing with wood processing equipment eventually proved too daunting.

So the evidence strongly suggests that using agricultural commodities as a supplement to biochemical production of something like ethanol is fine, but it’s silly and irresponsible to base an entire industry on an expectation that the agricultural feedstock will be available consistently, like wood chips, which are available on a regular basis.

While I have no doubt that logic will eventually prevail as it relates to the foundational raw material used in ethanol production, this puts the forest industry in a rather interesting position. It’s becoming obvious that wood fibre in all its forms is becoming more and more valuable. The work done to demonstrate just how many renewable, sustainable, and recyclable products can be derived from a tree has opened a lot of eyes. The quandary industry executives now face is how to divvy up that tree to maximize profit. What size, species, and percentage should go to solid wood, engineered wood products, pulp and paper, bio-energy and bio-chemicals?

The wood construction market is still a very good bet for solid wood and panelboard producers, but it seems to me that over the medium to long term, it makes a lot more sense for the pulp and paper industry to transition as quickly as possible to more bio-energy and bio-chemical production.