Cost
conscious cut-to-length
Setting
up a new CTL show in remote northern Manitoba, Art Riemer wanted dependable equipment -
but not at a price that would turn his accountant surly.
By Tony Kryzanowski
Copyright 1996. Contact publisher for permission to use.
Manitoba logger Art Riemer was hesitant when Repap Manitoba kept
insisting that he switch from a conventional tree-length harvesting system to a
cut-to-length system. But finally last fall, he took the plunge after reaching agreement
with the company on a contract rate. Now it was time to go shopping.
Riemer feels he made the right choice choosing an inexpensive
Fabtek 18'' processing head mounted on a John Deere 653E, as well as the six-wheel-drive
546 Fabtek rear bogie forwarder. The forwarder is the first sold in Western Canada.
Riemer logs about 100 kilometres from The Pas, near Cranberry
Portage in north central Manitoba. He supplies 50,000 m3 of fibre annually to the Repap
Manitoba sawmill in The Pas.
"The company that we worked for wanted a change," says
Riemer. "They were after better quality end product, more uniform size and a better
sort." Repap's desire for a better quality end product has a lot to do with the
quality of wood available in the area.
"We're working in really marginal wood," says Riemer.
"They (Repap) are trying to salvage as many sawlogs as they can out of it."
To put it in perspective, Riemer makes this observation about
his cutblocks. "What we have here is either rock or water, and very little in
between," he says. His company, suitably named Rocky Roads Logging, works year round
harvesting black spruce, white spruce and jack pine as small as 5'' in diameter, but
averaging 9'' to 10''.
His Fabtek 18'' four-roller processor, John Deere 653E and Fabtek
forwarder Manitoba logger Art Riemer was hesitant when Repap Manitoba kept insisting that
he switch from a conventional tree-length harvesting system to a cut-to-length system. But
finally last fall, he took the plunge after reaching agreement with the company on a
contract rate. Now it was time to go shopping.
Riemer feels he made the right choice choosing an inexpensive
Fabtek 18'' processing head mounted on a John Deere 653E, as well as the six-wheel-drive
546 Fabtek rear bogie forwarder. The forwarder is the first sold in Western Canada.
Riemer logs about 100 kilometres from The Pas, near Cranberry
Portage in north central Manitoba. He supplies 50,000 m3 of fibre annually to the Repap
Manitoba sawmill in The Pas. "The company that we worked for wanted a change,"
says Riemer. "They were after better quality end product, more uniform size and a
better sort."
Repap's desire for a better quality end product has a lot to do
with the quality of wood available in the area.
"We're working in really marginal wood," says Riemer.
"They (Repap) are trying to salvage as many sawlogs as they can out of it."
To put it in perspective, Riemer makes this observation about his
cutblocks. "What we have here is either rock or water, and very little in
between," he says. His company, suitably named Rocky Roads Logging, works year round
harvesting black spruce, white spruce and jack pine as small as 5'' in diameter, but
averaging 9'' to 10''.
A tour of the mill is like stepping through a time machine. The
mill employs 200 workers, operating a large and small log line dating back to the 1940's.
There were a few modifications installed over the past 20 years, but not many. EB Eddy
purchased the mill from Lajambe Forest Products in early 1995.
His Fabtek 18'' four-roller processor, John Deere 653E and Fabtek
forwarder were supplied by Brandt Tractor in Winnipeg. That's a 7-1/2-hour drive from
Cranberry Portage. The distance factor had plenty to do with Riemer's decision to purchase
a Fabtek processor and forwarder.
"Because we live where we do, we wanted something that was
going to be reliable," says Riemer. "Machines do break down. On the other hand,
if it does break down, I wanted something I could fix. That's the reason I went with the
Fabtek." He says both forwarder and processor are well built and easy to fix. They
were built in Michigan, and 95 per cent of their parts are available through any quality
hydraulic shop. Fabtek has designed the forwarder with popular John Deere components.
The Fabtek 546 forwarder is the company's largest unit, with a
rated payload capacity of 30,000 lbs. Riemer says he selected the largest forwarder
because of the long haul distances he sometimes requires. He has equipped the forwarder's
rear bogie wheels with Olofsfors tracks for better traction. The results have been
terrific.
"It will go places where it's questionable whether you can
walk," he says. "Loaded or empty, it will still go." He adds that he also
appreciates the forwarder's price tag. It cost him $270,000, which was considerably
cheaper than comparable bogie system units. As far as the price-to-horsepower ratio,
however, Riemer says nothing else came close.
The forwarder is equipped with a 6.8-litre, six-cylinder, 175-hp
turbo-charged engine. It has a John Deere 1200-series front axle, and a NAF 15-ton,
gear-driven rear bogie. The transmission is a four-speed power shift transmission with
electronic shift, and it also offers hydraulic differential lock. To fully tilt the
hydraulic tilting cab only takes one minute. The boom has an 18' reach, as well as a 51''
squirt boom extension. The grapple has continuous grapple rotation, and the hydraulic
system is a closed centre system. For extra stability, the forwarder has automatic
hydraulic frame lockout when loading.
Riemer says loggers will notice similarities between this
forwarder and John Deere skidders.
"The way this Fabtek forwarder is designed, it looks like
a skidder," he says. "It's designed from a John Deere skidder. It's strong,
functional, has lots of power, and is easy on fuel. And it's not hard to learn to use at
all." Given their rocky terrain, he says he needs the horsepower provided by the
Fabtek forwarder.
Riemer knows a lot about skidders because that was his main line
of work prior to evolving into a cut-to-length system. He has been logging since 1975,
starting with hand felling and then advancing to a semi-mechanical system. He operated a
skidder with a roto limb attachment on the blade. This system still required the skidder
operator to dismount and chain saw remaining limbs and tops before skidding to roadside.
While this cut-to-length system has yet to prove itself
economically, Riemer believes that it will eventually, once they feel comfortable with
their equipment and begin operating at higher production levels. So far, it has been a
learning experience.
"I think for our area, it's a better way of logging,"
he says, "because with the old feller buncher, you were always up against room.
Basically, there was no room to work in the gullies and in the rock ridges." And
considering how the feller buncher laid out the wood for delimbing, it was difficult for
the skidder to back-blade the limbs.
"Whereas this system, once you cut the tree and drop it, you
are finished with it and the forwarder comes in," says Riemer. "With the
cut-to-length system, you drive over all the debris, so it's a bonus. It's easier on
tires. It's not like a skidder where you are right in the nitty-gritty all the time and
spinning around. Basically, with the forwarder, you never spin a wheel."
While it has never come up as an issue, Riemer says he would not
be surprised if Repap had a concern about environmental damage, considering the mess left
behind using their old system. "It was terrible," Riemer says. "When you
were finished an area, it was all rutted up and it wasn't very nice to look at. We have
people driving by now on the road after we have cut an area, and they are impressed with
the amount of re-gen wood that is left standing."
It just stands to reason, he says, with less equipment more
re-gen will be left standing. The John Deere processing unit and the Fabtek forwarder have
replaced a feller buncher, a delimber, a grapple skidder forwarder and a slasher.
"If there is no need to drive through it, you don't with the
cut-to-length system," says Riemer. "If you are working next to an old cut, like
a 15- to 20-year-old cut, you don't have to drive in at all. You don't fall wood into the
re-gen. Everything is contained in the area that you are working in."
However, because of the marginal stands in Riemer's cutblocks, he
must push past a considerable amount of 2'' and 3'' stems to reach better quality wood.
Therefore, the sturdy forwarder bumper has come in handy.
"Lots of equipment out there have blades, but they are more
or less just a bumper," he says. "I don't really see any function for
them." Conversely, he finds the Fabtek forwarder blade very functional for clearing a
path.
Rocky Road Logging has put about 400 hours on their Fabtek
forwarder. Both their forwarder and processor unit arrived in the fall. While Riemer
described Fabtek's offer of training as "minimal" he says it was not required.
Operators can easily learn from the operational and parts manual, because the equipment is
easy to operate. Only plenty of "time in the seat" helped Rocky Road Logging
operators make the transition to a new style of logging.
"Being a strong and durable unit, we never had trouble with
breaking things that shouldn't have been breaking," he says.
The only minor improvement that he could recommend is improvement
to the forwarder's boom float system. Fabtek has acknowledged his feedback and are working
to correct the problem.
The boom system, he says, is mounted on the front half of the
machine, so when the operator turns the forwarder, the boom has to have a float system so
it can pivot.
"What happens if you are not careful and have jammed in the
load good, when you are driving with your load, at times it (the boom) could tip off the
load and knock some of the trees off," says Riemer. However, he is confident Fabtek
will solve this minor concern. Riemer has overnight bus service on parts. He says Brandt
Tractor and Fabtek have responded well to any minor problems he has come across. And if a
problem does crop up, he is confident he can fix it himself. |