Getting our economic mojo back—with a new softwood lumber deal

By Tony Kryzanowski

There are questions being raised globally about whether Canada has lost its economic mojo, as StatsCan recently reported that economic growth in this country is plodding along at its slowest pace in 60 years. Between 2014 and 2016, Gross Domestic Product (GDP) grew by only 1.2 percent, and while that may be a bit of an anomaly, GDP still seems stuck in the two percent per year range.

Enter the federal government’s new five-year $950 million Innovation Superclusters Initiative (ISI), which will provide matching funds to five approved innovation superclusters in the areas of advanced manufacturing, agri-food, clean technology, digital technology, health and bio-sciences, clean resources, and infrastructure and transportation.

It’s the federal government’s attempt to help industry reclaim our mojo with the development of new intellectual properties that demonstrate Canada’s leadership and ability to drive global innovation—but one is left wondering if the same couldn’t be accomplished with more effort instead on negotiating a new softwood lumber agreement and construction of a couple of pipelines.

There are a growing number of new commercial products being developed from novel, wood-based, raw materials through investments made in research, development and innovation over the past decade. Fundamentally, as far as the forest industry is concerned, past research and development programs have worked, with development of new, more efficient ways to extract highly-refined lignin, cellulose nanocrystals and forest-based fuel alternatives from wood fibre. And some very important lessons have been learned along the way, the most important being the benefit of ‘drop-in’ technology, where companies can pursue production of these novel products without disrupting their conventional production methods.

So, perhaps there is the potential for a bid from the forest industry for funding from the ISI program through its forest research institute, FPInnovations, to at least prepare a Letter of Intent to file a formal application under the ISI program by the July deadline.

With the program’s focus on promoting cross pollination across various industrial sectors and development of industrial superclusters, this could be an opportunity to step beyond the current focus on improving manufacturing processes—and begin to seriously investigate large-scale industrial and commercial applications of these novel raw materials into bio-based panel board resins; renewable jet fuel; iridescent and magnetic films; pigments, paints, and cosmetics; improved construction products; innovative coatings; paper fillers; and innovative bioplastics.

But there is a time for greater investment in innovation, and from a forest industry perspective, the ISI program seems like a distraction, and the wrong prescription for what currently ails the Canadian economy.

At a time when our biggest trading partner is talking trade protection and massive softwood lumber tariffs, now is not the time to distract our forest sector with new innovation programs. Innovation requires a significant investment in both time and money—neither of which are in great supply within the forestry industry at the present time as companies build reserves to survive a protracted softwood lumber trade dispute.

The ISI program is complicated, built upon advanced economic concepts like industry clusters and superclusters, requiring the attention of human resources that should be working on the trade file instead of trying to decipher bureaucratic jargon to create a grant application that may or may not succeed. Also, the $950 million will only match what industry and its partners contribute to its supercluster. Third, each supercluster must have at least one university partner and must have an industry sponsor.

So, based on the fine print alone, it seems quite obvious that the federal government already has a fairly good idea where it is going to spend its money with this program, and suffice to say, it will be in locations where well-established industrial clusters already exist.

Investment in innovation has its place, but the reality is that right now, the forest industry has to keep its eye on the bigger, more immediate prize, which is some sort of new agreement on softwood lumber exports to the United States. The only reason why the industry has managed to survive the tariff by the Americans on Canadian softwood lumber without a major collapse thus far is the current high price being paid for our lumber by the American building industry. But as one industry veteran recently pointed out, this market won’t last forever. Watch out if demand and prices drop.

Thousands of forestry jobs—often in remote communities in one-resource towns—are at stake, representing the middle class that our Prime Minister assures us is among his biggest priorities. Or is it?

Time will tell if softwood lumber will be forced to take a back seat for months or years as Canada attempts to negotiate a new North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) with the U.S. and Mexico. The comment has already been heard several times from our federal leaders that the government is loathe to make waves over an industry that exports $2 billion per year to the U.S., when NAFTA allows for trade with our American counterparts to the tune of $2 billion per day.

Logging and Sawmilling Journal
June/July 2017

On the Cover:
The Seneca Sawmill Company has been part of the Eugene, Oregon landscape for more than 60 years. It’s now nearing the completion of a second $65 million upgrade which included upgrading the dimensional mill with new equipment and technology, installing additional dry kilns and upgrading its dimension mill planer (Photo by Diane Mettler).

More computers in the cutblock
For the forest industry, the cutblock is expected to be the focus of advanced systems and technology for equipment over the short term—but don’t expect to see any logging equipment without operators quite yet.

Tracked performance—without the tracks
Moore’s Logging of Alberta says its new TimberPro 840C combo machine—an eight-wheeled forestry machine which can function as a harvester, processor, forwarder or clam bunk skidder—is able to deliver track machine power, without the track machine issues.

Solving steep slope challenges—to a T
The T-Winch, a new to Canada, European-developed tethered skidder assist system, is solving multiple steep slope issues for Alberta logger Kelly McGlynn.

Seneca sees second mill upgrade
The Seneca Sawmill Company in Oregon is nearing the completion of a second $65 million upgrade which—on the heels of a similar size upgrade during the recession—means a total investment of $130 million, clearly reflecting the confidence the company’s owners have in the industry.

Bonus Christmas gift
The residents of Hornepayne, Ontario received a bonus Christmas gift late last year, with the shuttered sawmill/biomass power plant in the town coming back to life, thanks to industry veteran, Frank Dottori.

The Edge
Included in this edition of The Edge, Canada’s leading publication on research in the forest industry, are stories from the Canadian Wood Fibre Centre, Alberta Innovates, Alberta Agriculture, the Forest Products Association of Canada and FPInnovations.

The Last Word
It’s time for Canada to get our economic mojo back—with a new softwood lumber deal, says Tony Kryzanowski.


Tech Update

Supplier Newsline

For all the latest industry news, subscribe to our twice monthly newsletter!


* indicates required