The Last Word

Fort McMurray fire could have ripple effect on cost of insurance for the forest industry

By Jim Stirling

Loggers justifiably grumble about the rising costs of simply staying in business. Day to day operating expenses like tires, gas and equipment parts consistently trend upwards. Now the implications of a warming climate are poised to add a few more grey hairs—and potential bills for loggers and truckers.

Higher temperatures punctuated by more extreme weather patterns are occurring more frequently. One of the more direct, and costly, effects of those are the increasing risks of wildfires. When wildfires become more intense and unpredictable, the damage caused can be catastrophic. Eventually, someone or something has to foot the bill.

It’s what insurance is for and the premiums paid for it—general liability, equipment and property, for example—respond to the broader market forces that influence it. Insurance companies estimate the Fort McMurray wildfire in northern Alberta this May will cost them $3.58 billion.

“There is little doubt that the Fort McMurray wildfire is one of the most horrific and damaging natural disasters in Canadian history,” declared Bill Adams during a conference call after the damage figures had been tabulated. Adams is vice-president, western and pacific, with the Insurance Bureau of Canada. “The vast majority of the overall costs of the fire will be borne by insurance policies,” he added.

The $3.58 billion is a mind boggling figure and eclipses the previous costliest insured disaster in Canadian history, the Quebec ice storm of 1998.That event cost insurers about $1.9 billion in 2014 dollars, reckons the Insurance Bureau of Canada. The flooding in southern Alberta cost around $1.8 billion in insurable claims while the forest fire that almost wiped out Slave Lake, Alberta in 2011 cost about $742 million in claims.

The Fort McMurray conflagration destroyed more than 1,800 detached homes and 600 other housing units around the city. It forced major oilsands extraction companies to curtail production by around one million barrels of oil a day for two weeks.

The wildfire’s influence was far reaching. Statistics Canada figures show the real gross domestic product in Canada contracted by 0.6 per cent in May. Statistics Canada attributed that to the economic fallout from the forest fires.

The effects of the Fort McMurray fire are also likely to filter down to the logger and trucker, especially for those working in Alberta. The province now has the unenviable record of being the site for seven out of the 10 most expensive Canadian insured disasters. The Insurance Bureau of Canada’s Adams was cagey: “What impact this will have on (policy costs) will be determined at a later date by individual insurers.”

Wildfires routinely cause interruptions to production schedules and cash flows for logging contractors and licencees. Wildfire risks curtail bush operating hours for the forest industry—and trigger outright work shutdowns.

On occasion, the forest industry is blamed for causing a forest fire or allowing one to get worse. A case in point focused on the cause of a June 2010 forest fire southeast of Vanderhoof, in central British Columbia. The Crown alleged the licencee and its subcontractor doing the logging were negligent in the blaze.

The Crown argued that flammable debris near the exhaust of a feller buncher likely caused smouldering on the forest floor which subsequently ignited. The logging block contained predominantly beetle-killed lodgepole pine. The province was seeking about $5.5 million in damages, it claimed were attributable to lengthy suppression costs on the stubborn 6,100 hectare fire; lost stumpage value; the lost value of immature timber stands and reforestation costs.

The B.C. Supreme Court Justice hearing the issue ruled in July 2016 that the provincial government had not proved its case. “In my view, the province has not established that it is more likely than not the fire started as a result of the (harvesting) operation,” Justice Bruce Greyell said in his judgment. “In my view, there is a fair inference to be drawn that the fire was a holdover fire which was the result of lightning on the (previous) evening of June 17.”

The case reinforces the need for heightened vigilance during warm weather harvesting operations. And it emphasizes the wisdom in investing in comprehensive insurance packages.

The effect on those premiums from the Fort McMurray wildfire is hard to predict. “But it will spill over,” believes Hedley Larson, an insurance broker at Capri Insurance Services’ Vernon, B.C. office. Larson has been selling insurance for about 25 years and represents 30 to 40 different insurance companies. He specializes in the commercial sector, including heavy equipment in the logging and mining industries. The home insurance sector might be the first to feel the pinch, given the heavy losses incurred there in the Fort McMurray fires, he surmises. Larson noted loggers’ insurance premiums have been pretty steady for the last several years. “But they are claim-based and every contractor is a bit different.” Loggers who haven’t made an insurance claim in 20 years of operation are obviously in a better position than those who have filed two or three claims, he points out.

“My crystal ball is no better than anyone else’s, but will all individual contractors experience cost increases? Probably not. I don’t expect that,” he says. But losses on the scale of the Fort McMurray wildfires bring home the importance of having adequate insurance with a reputable company, adds Larson.

Logging and Sawmilling Journal
September 2016

On the Cover:
The Weyerhaeuser sawmill in Princeton, B.C. has added two new Volvo wheel loaders, a Volvo L350F and a Volvo L150H, from B.C. Volvo dealer Great West Equipment to help manage log operations. Read about how the equipment is helping make the operation more efficient beginning on page 10. (Photo by Paul MacDonald).

Tapping into the growing bio-economy at Alberta’s Bio-Mile
A new $11 million Clean Energy Technology Centre recently opened in Alberta and among its goals is supporting greater product diversification within the forestry sector, and encouraging more participation by the industry in the bio-economy.

Volvos delivering volume
Some new Volvo wheel loaders are helping the Weyerhaeuser sawmill in Princeton, B.C. deliver efficiencies in the millyard, in feeding logs into the high production, two-line sawmill, and handling chips and hog fuel.

“Big Data” already being utilized by forest industry
Although “Big Data” has become a buzz term in business circles in recent years, the forest industry is already well on its way to using Big Data in a number of areas, from machine centres at the sawmill, to woodlands operations.

Hard work = successful sawmill
Though it requires a lot of hard work, Alberta sawmiller Colin Ruxton says that small sawmilling can pay off—and he’s proven it with both a band and circular sawmill.

Going from logger—to lumber producer
New Brunswick’s Pierre Friolet has used skills developed as a logging contractor to set up an added-value operation that produces thermally modified wood, finding customers from architects to guitar makers for the unique wood product.

Lean log handling
B.C.’s coastal forest industry and the provincial government are working on streamlining the log handling process through making changes based on the “Lean” philosophy that is practiced in other industries—and it’s already showing results.

Family fencing operation
B.C. specialty mill operation Nagaard Sawmill, run by brothers Darrol and Dale Nagel, has found its niche—and it’s in producing fence components from western red cedar for a growing market, with a mill that features a fair bit of home-made equipment, and lots of ingenuity.

Liking the Log Max/Doosan combo
New Brunswick harvesting contractor Remi Doucet is a fan of the Doosan/Log Max harvesting combination, and recently upgraded his equipment with a new Log Max 7000 head.

BUILDER of business relationships
B.C. logger Shane Garner says a successful harvesting contracting operation is all about business relationships, from his employees to his John Deere-heavy logging equipment fleet.

A life in logging: from horses—to Tigercats
Long time logger Alan Costain may have started with yarding horses, but these days the horsepower in Costain Lumbering is of a very different sort, with equipment such as a Tigercat 822.

Self-sufficient sawmilling
The frontier community of Colville Lake, 50 kilometres north of the Arctic Circle in the Northwest Territories, has acquired a new portable sawmill which will produce building materials to help address the community’s need for improved housing.

The Edge
Included in this edition of The Edge, Canada’s leading publication on research in the forest industry, are stories from the Canadian Wood Fibre Centre and Alberta Innovates - Bio Solutions.

The Last Word
The Fort McMurray fire of earlier this year could have ripple effect on the cost of insurance for the forest industry, says Jim Stirling.


Supplier Newsline

For all the latest industry news, subscribe to our twice monthly newsletter!


* indicates required